🧩 Philosophy 7h ago · Our Critical Point

Reinforcement Learning is Probably Inconsistent with Ethics

Less Wrong
View Channel →
Source ↗ 👁 0 💬 0
"Reinforcement learning is evil." - Yoshua BengioI agree with Bengio here, though I have an argument I haven't seen elsewhere.[1]A standard argument for reinforcement learning being dangerous goes like this: reinforcement learning requires you to specify a reward function; specifying a reward function which captures all of ethics is really hard; so we will specify a proxy of ethics instead; powerful optimizers will game any proxy objective; so RL trained AIs will game our proxy of ethics; so RL

Comments (0)

Sign in to join the discussion

More Like This

📰
Directly Ascertained Volition (DAV) to safeguard personal autonomy
LessWrong · 1h ago
Catching split attacks across compactions in long-context coding agents
LessWrong · 7h ago
Models Trained to Evade Topic Probes Struggle to Answer Questions about Those Topics
LessWrong · 7h ago
How Researchers Lie to AIs
LessWrong · 8h ago
📰
When AI Advice Shapes the Evidence It Later Interprets
LessWrong · 8h ago
More Capable Models Write Better Probe Evasion Prompts
LessWrong · 8h ago